I proposed to my girlfriend on the dock – and here’s how it happened

He wanted a “yes” but got a mess.

In theory, a “will you marry me” moment by the water is great. But when the ring falls into the water, you know what happens.

“Oh, crap,” the bride-to-be sighed as she accidentally knocked her boxed engagement ring out of her fiancé’s hands into the shallow lake.

New York model and soon-to-be sister-in-law McKenna Hiller’s viral video of the man’s proposal goes from sweet to soggy as a rock rolls off a dock into something wet , his face dropped.

“That’s typical of us,” the groom-to-be said with a laugh after a beer bottle was also knocked over on the dock.

The shocking clip, which has racked up a staggering 647,000 views on Instagram, drew congratulations from fans and sideways glances from skeptics – many of whom believed the future bride’s diamond dunk was no silly accident.

“She didn’t want to marry him and tried to laugh through it [it]feeling embarrassed and not wanting to say ‘no’ on camera,” one cynic argued in the comments.

“How sad,” wrote another. “The guy didn’t even realize he was in the friend zone the whole time.”

Trolls also accused the man of creating a huge disaster for himself.

“Can we please stop proposing over bodies of water,” complained one critic.

“Why people still propose on the pier [and] Pier,” asked an equally bewildered onlooker. “We all saw this happen. “

They may be right.

Katie Nicholson, 24, found herself on an “emotional rollercoaster” after briefly throwing the square-cut gemstone into the sea at her fiancé Steve’s request.

Thanks to a kind passerby, the gem was quickly recovered.

Australian groom-to-be Zay staged an elaborate engagement scene for his fiancée Sai on Sydney’s Coogee Beach ahead of Valentine’s Day 2023, only for it to lose its luster on the beach. Online onlookers dismissed Shore’s proposal as “a nightmare”.

Ross Bamber, 26, from England, said he had just given a $1,200 ring to his then-girlfriend, Geri Ashforth, 23, before he could even order it. He fell to his knees and plopped into the lake, and his heart was broken.

“I took the ring out of my pocket and when I opened the box, it fell out,” he recalled in 2022. “It bounced a few times and then fell into a crack in the floor.”

Ashford later announced on social media that despite her and Bamber’s best efforts, “our ring has been lost in the lake forever.”

However, Shearer, who captured the latest incident on video, was unwilling to let her sister and soon-to-be brother-in-law suffer a similar fate.

Seconds after the couple’s token of love stirred up the water, the New York beauty jumped into the water to save it from sinking.

“It doesn’t float perfectly,” Shearer gushed about the floating piece of jewelry. “As a little sister, my instinct wasn’t to just jump right in.”