Butt Plug Questions

Hi all, I recently tried a butt plug and I have a few questions regarding the experience.

First, [this]( is the product I used. During sex, it continuously felt like it was going to slip out, and at one point actually popped out from my partner’s thrusting. The insertion itself was easy, but the stimulation felt like I was pooping.

Do I need a larger plug that has a smaller neck? Will a larger plug feel better ? My partner said I am a more elastic down there compared to previous people he’s been with (despite never having done anal play before) so I’m wondering if I need to size up. Also does the pooping sensation ever get better lol or is it due to the shape/size of my toy?

Thanks!

View Reddit by heckyeafriends – View Source